Understanding Arc Flash Boundaries: Limited, Restricted & Arc

Working with energized electrical conductors presents significant dangers, with an electrical explosion, or arc flash, being one of the most severe. To protect personnel, the NFPA 70E standard establishes three critical approach boundaries: the Arc Flash Boundary, the Limited Approach Boundary, and the Restricted Approach Boundary. These arc flash boundaries define specific distances from a potential hazard, each dictating the level of training and personal protective equipment (PPE) required. The Arc Flash Boundary is established using incident-energy calculations to identify the distance at which calculated thermal energy can cause serious burns. The Limited and Restricted boundaries are designed to reduce the risk of shock hazard. Only a qualified person, as defined in NFPA 70E and trained for the hazards and tasks, may cross the inner boundaries, and they must use appropriate arc-rated clothing and other safety gear. Properly identifying and respecting these boundaries through an arc flash risk assessment is fundamental to electrical safety and preventing catastrophic injuries.

What are Arc Flash Approach Boundaries?

An arc flash is a dangerous and rapid release of energy due to an electrical fault that can produce intense thermal energy, pressure waves, and projected molten metal or debris. To mitigate these risks, the NFPA 70E, Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace, defines a system of approach boundaries. These are specified approach boundaries around energized electrical equipment that indicate what precautions, PPE, and qualifications are required before a person may approach or work on the equipment. There are two distinct types of hazards these boundaries address: thermal energy from an arc flash and electric shock from direct or indirect contact. This leads to three primary boundaries every master electrician and journeyman electrician must know: the Arc Flash Boundary, the Limited Approach Boundary, and the Restricted Approach Boundary.

The Arc Flash Boundary (Flash Protection Boundary)

The Arc Flash Boundary, also called the flash protection boundary, is typically the outermost boundary. It is established where calculated incident energy reaches a level associated with the onset of a second-degree burn; industry guidance commonly references about 1.2 calories per square centimeter (cal/cm²) as a practical indicator for that threshold. Anyone crossing inside this boundary to perform work must be a qualified person and be protected by appropriate arc-rated clothing and other PPE selected based on the incident-energy or PPE-category assessment required by NFPA 70E and IEEE incident-energy methods.

The Limited Approach Boundary

The Limited Approach Boundary is one of the shock-protection approach boundaries defined by NFPA 70E; it identifies a restricted distance for unqualified persons and prescribes controls and qualifications for those who approach energized parts. Unqualified individuals, such as painters or general laborers, should not cross this boundary. A qualified person with appropriate training may cross it but must follow the shock-protection requirements and use the suitable PPE and procedures specified by NFPA 70E.

The Restricted Approach Boundary

The Restricted Approach Boundary is the more limited shock-protection zone and indicates the closer distance at which additional protective measures (insulation, live-line tools, voltage-rated gloves, a documented work plan, etc.) are required; NFPA 70E specifies that only a qualified person with the appropriate training and safeguards may enter this zone. Entering this area typically requires a higher level of planning, protective equipment, and controls consistent with NFPA 70E guidance.

How to Determine Arc Flash Boundaries

Establishing accurate arc flash boundaries is a critical component of a comprehensive electrical safety program and is required for proper equipment labeling. While software tools are commonly used, the process generally follows these steps, guided by incident-energy calculation methods such as IEEE 1584 and the procedures referenced in NFPA 70E:

1. Gather System and Equipment Data: Collect detailed information about the electrical system. This includes system voltages, available fault currents, transformer data (kVA, impedance), conductor sizes, and the types and settings of all overcurrent protective devices like fuses and circuit breakers. (System data collection is the starting point for any arc-flash study.)
2. Perform an Arc Flash Risk Assessment: This engineering analysis, often called an arc flash study, uses the collected data to calculate potential hazards. For some standard equipment configurations, NFPA 70E provides PPE-category tables that can be used in the field; for a precise determination of incident energy and boundaries, an incident-energy analysis in accordance with IEEE 1584 is used.
3. Calculate Incident Energy: Using the data from the assessment, calculate the prospective incident energy at a specified working distance. This value, measured in calories per square centimeter (cal/cm²), represents the thermal energy a worker could be exposed to. The calculation accounts for the arcing current and the duration of the arc, which depends on how quickly upstream protective devices will clear the fault (per NFPA 70E and IEEE incident-energy methods).
4. Determine the Approach Boundaries: Based on the calculations, establish the three boundaries. The Arc Flash Boundary is the distance at which incident energy reaches a level associated with significant burn potential. The Limited and Restricted Approach Boundaries are based on shock-protection criteria and system voltage information as described in NFPA 70E.
5. Create and Apply Warning Labels: The results of the study must be documented on arc-flash warning labels affixed to the equipment. NEC Article 110 includes marking requirements for equipment likely to be serviced while energized, and NFPA 70E provides guidance on the label content commonly used (for example, nominal system voltage and incident energy or PPE category). For more on new labeling rules and practice, consult NFPA 70E and IEEE/industry guidance.

The Role of PPE and the Qualified Worker

Boundaries are only effective when personnel understand and respect them. This hinges on two key elements: having a properly trained workforce and using the correct personal protective equipment (PPE).

NFPA 70E defines a qualified person as someone who “has demonstrated skills and knowledge related to the construction and operation of electrical equipment and installations and who has received safety training to identify and avoid the hazards involved.” This is not merely general electrician training; it is training and demonstrated competency specifically related to electrical hazards and the equipment being worked on, as defined by NFPA 70E.

When a task requires crossing an arc flash boundary, the qualified person must be equipped with appropriate PPE determined by the incident-energy calculation or PPE-category method in NFPA 70E. PPE ranges from arc-rated clothing for lower incident-energy levels to arc-rated suits and specialized equipment for higher-energy exposures. Ensuring every journeyman electrician and master electrician on site understands how to select, inspect, and use their PPE is an essential part of an electrical safety program.

Master electrical safety concepts with our detailed NFPA 70E courses.

Beyond Boundaries: Important Safety Considerations

While understanding boundaries and PPE is crucial, the safest approach to any electrical task is to establish an electrically safe work condition (de-energize). When de-energizing is not feasible, other risk mitigation strategies should be employed. Key considerations include:

• Engineering Controls: Reducing incident energy is a primary goal. This can be achieved by installing faster-acting protective devices, current-limiting fuses, or arc-detection and mitigation systems that shorten the duration of an arc.
• Equipment Maintenance: Regular maintenance of protective devices and equipment is essential; a poorly maintained breaker or fuse may not operate as intended and can increase incident energy exposure.
• Working Space: Adhering to the NEC working-space and access requirements (NEC Article 110) is critical. Adequate space allows a worker to move freely and escape a hazardous area without being hindered. For more on the NEC working clearance requirements, see NEC working clearance requirements (110.26). You may also find changes to working space access and egress helpful.
• Documentation and Planning: For any work inside the Restricted Approach Boundary, a formal plan should be created and, where required by company policy or NFPA 70E, an energized work permit and pre-job briefing should be completed to ensure all risks are considered and controls are in place.

Primary Sources

• NFPA 70E®, Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace® (https://www.nfpa.org/70E)
• OSHA 29 CFR 1910 Subpart S – Electrical (https://www.osha.gov)
• IEEE 1584, Guide for Performing Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations (https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8662228)

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most important arc flash boundary?

All three arc flash boundaries are important for different reasons: the Arc Flash Boundary addresses thermal energy (burn) risk, while the Limited and Restricted Approach Boundaries address electric shock hazard. Which is most important depends on the specific task and the relative proximity of the worker to the energized electrical conductors.

How does an arc fault breaker help prevent arc flashes?

An arc-fault circuit interrupter (AFCI) is designed to detect the signature of hazardous arcing in branch circuits and de-energize the circuit to reduce fire risk. For industrial hazards, other rapid arc-detection and mitigation systems (designed for higher voltages and currents) are employed to reduce incident energy and improve worker safety.

What training is required to be a qualified person?

To be considered a qualified person under NFPA 70E, an individual must have demonstrated skills and knowledge related to the construction and operation of electrical equipment and installations and have received safety training to identify and avoid electrical hazards. This includes understanding approach boundaries, PPE selection, and safe work practices described in NFPA 70E.

What is the difference between arc flash and shock hazard boundaries?

The key difference is the hazard they protect against. The Arc Flash Boundary focuses on thermal energy and potential burn injuries (set using incident-energy calculations). The Limited and Restricted Approach Boundaries are shock-protection boundaries that depend on system voltage and specific shock-protection criteria in NFPA 70E.