How to Perform a Solar Shading Analysis for PV System Design

A solar shading analysis is a critical process in PV system design that evaluates how surrounding objects—like trees, buildings, and chimneys—will cast shadows on a solar array throughout the year. For any licensed master electrician or journeyman electrician, performing this analysis correctly is essential for maximizing a system’s energy output, ensuring financial returns, and achieving client satisfaction. A thorough analysis involves a detailed site assessment, the use of specialized tools like a Solar Pathfinder or software such as PVsyst and HelioScope, and quantifying potential energy losses. This data directly informs optimal panel placement, proper PV string sizing, and the selection of shading loss mitigation technologies. Ultimately, a precise solar shading analysis is a cornerstone of a high-performing solar panel generator, ensuring the project’s long-term performance and bankability.

Why a Solar Shading Analysis is Critical for Professional Electricians

For any residential electrician, journeyman electrician, or master electrician involved in the solar industry, a solar shading analysis is not just a best practice—it’s a fundamental step for ensuring system quality and performance. Even a small amount of shade on a single solar cell can disproportionately reduce the output of the entire string of panels, a phenomenon sometimes called the “Christmas light effect.” This reduction in energy production directly impacts the system’s return on investment. Furthermore, a project’s financial viability, or bankability, often depends on accurate energy production estimates, which are impossible without accounting for shade. Lenders and investors require confidence that a project will perform as projected, and a detailed shading report provides that assurance. Failing to perform this analysis can lead to underperforming systems, dissatisfied customers, and potential liability for the installer.

Understanding the Fundamentals: Key Concepts in Shading

Solar Irradiance and Its Importance

Solar irradiance is the measure of solar power received per unit area, typically expressed in watts per square meter (W/m²). It is the raw fuel for any solar panel generator. When an object casts a shadow on a panel, it directly blocks this incoming energy, reducing the panel’s ability to generate electricity. The goal of a shading analysis is to map where and when these obstructions will block sunlight, allowing designers to quantify the expected reduction in irradiance over the course of a day and throughout the seasons.

Azimuth and Tilt Angle

Two critical parameters in any site assessment are the azimuth and tilt angles. The Azimuth angle refers to the orientation of the solar panels in relation to the compass directions. While conventions can vary, it is typically measured in degrees with 0° as true north, increasing clockwise, making 180° due south in the Northern Hemisphere. The Tilt angle is the degree of incline of the panels relative to the horizontal plane. Both angles are optimized to maximize the capture of solar irradiance. A shading analysis must consider these angles, as they determine how shadows from surrounding objects will move across the array during different times of the day and year.

The Impact of Shading on a Solar Array

In a traditional string of solar panels, the cells are connected in series. The electric current must flow through every cell, so the performance of the entire string is limited by the weakest-performing cell. When one cell is shaded, its current production drops, creating a bottleneck that reduces the output of all other un-shaded cells in the string. To prevent severe damage from this effect, panels are equipped with Bypass diodes. These diodes create an alternate path for the current to flow around the shaded section of the panel, but this also means that portion of the panel is no longer producing power.

Step-by-Step Guide to Performing a Solar Shading Analysis

A professional solar shading analysis combines on-site measurements with powerful software modeling. Here is a step-by-step process for conducting a thorough analysis:

1. Conduct a Comprehensive Site Assessment: Begin with a physical and visual inspection of the site. Identify and document all potential sources of shading, including trees, adjacent buildings, vents, chimneys, and utility poles. It’s important to not only consider current obstacles but also potential future ones, like the projected growth of young trees.
2. Gather Sun Path and Positional Data: Determine the sun’s path for the specific geographic location. This involves knowing the site’s latitude and understanding the sun’s altitude and azimuth angles throughout the year. This data forms the basis for predicting where shadows will fall in every season.
3. Use Specialized Analysis Tools:
   • Manual Tools: The Solar Pathfinder is a classic, non-electronic tool used for decades. It uses a reflective dome to provide a 360-degree view of the site, reflecting all potential shade-casting objects onto a sun path diagram for the specific latitude. An installer can then trace these obstructions to get a clear, year-round picture of when the array will be shaded.
   • Digital Software: Modern analysis heavily relies on software like PVsyst and HelioScope. These programs allow designers to create a 3D model of the site and its surroundings. By inputting object dimensions and locations, the software can generate highly accurate reports on annual shading losses, often expressed as a percentage of total potential energy production.
4. Quantify Shading Losses: The output from the analysis tools will quantify the total energy loss due to shading. This is often represented as a “shading coefficient” or a percentage of total solar access. For example, a result might show 95% solar access, indicating an estimated 5% annual energy loss from shading. This data is crucial for financial modeling and setting realistic performance expectations.
5. Integrate Findings into System Design: Use the shading report to optimize the final system design. This includes adjusting panel layouts to avoid the most heavily shaded areas and making informed decisions on PV string sizing. For instance, it may be better to create shorter strings in partially shaded zones to isolate the impact.

Complying with the NEC and Industry Standards

While a shading analysis is primarily a performance and design task, all solar installations must comply with the NFPA 70, also known as the NEC code book. NEC Article 690 provides the core requirements for solar photovoltaic systems, covering everything from circuit sizing and overcurrent protection to disconnecting means and rapid shutdown. Although Article 690 doesn’t explicitly mandate a shading analysis, the results of the analysis directly influence decisions that are governed by the code, such as conductor sizing and inverter specifications. Understanding these regulations is a key part of any professional electrician training and is essential for passing certification exams. For those preparing for exams, focusing on practical applications of the code, such as those found in advanced journeyman electrician exam calculations, is highly beneficial.

Strategies for Shading Loss Mitigation

When shading is unavoidable, several technologies and design strategies can be employed to minimize its impact. Proper shading loss mitigation is a hallmark of a well-designed system.

• Module-Level Power Electronics (MLPE): This is the most effective solution for mitigating shade. MLPEs include Microinverters and Power optimizers. Microinverters convert DC to AC power at each individual panel, so a shaded panel does not affect the output of any other. Power optimizers are DC-to-DC converters that condition the power from each panel, ensuring a shaded module doesn’t reduce the performance of the entire string.
• Strategic Stringing and Panel Layout: Designers can minimize shade impact by arranging strings to isolate shaded areas. For example, if a chimney casts a shadow in the morning, all panels affected by that shadow can be placed on a separate, shorter string, preventing them from impacting the production of the main array.
• Use of Bypass Diodes: While standard in most modern panels, understanding the function of bypass diodes is key. They ensure that current can “bypass” a shaded cell or group of cells, preventing a catastrophic drop in the entire string’s output, though the bypassed section contributes no power.
• Advanced Electrical Calculations: Proper PV string sizing is crucial. In some cases, complex designs might benefit from advanced knowledge, similar to what is required in a three-phase electrical calculations guide, to ensure optimal performance across multiple sub-arrays with different conditions.

The Future of Solar and the Need for Electrician Training

The solar industry continues to expand, offering significant growth opportunities for licensed electricians. Keeping pace with evolving technologies and standards requires a commitment to ongoing electrician training. As opportunities grow, such as the trends seen in Colorado’s burgeoning solar market, the demand for highly skilled installers will increase. Whether through comprehensive online electrical courses or hands-on workshops, staying current on topics like shading analysis, NEC updates, and new mitigation technologies is essential for professional success.

Ready to become an expert in PV system design and installation? Master PV design with our NABCEP certification prep courses.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the most important tool for a solar shading analysis?

While traditional tools like the Solar Pathfinder are highly reliable for on-site readings, modern digital software like PVsyst and HelioScope are considered indispensable for a comprehensive solar shading analysis. They allow for the creation of detailed 3D models and provide precise annual energy loss calculations, which are essential for the bankability of commercial projects and the accuracy of residential proposals.

How does shading affect PV string sizing and compliance with NEC Article 690?

Shading directly impacts PV string sizing by influencing the operational voltage and current of the modules. A heavily shaded string may not reach the minimum voltage required for the inverter to operate efficiently. While NEC Article 690 governs the safety aspects of string design, such as maximum voltage based on cold temperatures, performance-based decisions from a shading analysis ensure the system works effectively in real-world conditions.

Can microinverters or power optimizers completely eliminate shading losses?

No, they cannot eliminate shading losses entirely, but they significantly mitigate them. A shaded panel will still produce less power because it’s receiving less sunlight. However, microinverters and power optimizers ensure that the reduced output of one shaded panel does not drag down the performance of the unshaded panels in the array, thereby maximizing the total system production under shaded conditions.

Is a solar shading analysis required for every residential electrician installing a PV system?

While not an explicit code requirement in most jurisdictions, performing a solar shading analysis is a professional standard of care. For any residential electrician, it is a critical step to ensure the system performs as promised, to provide accurate financial return estimates to the homeowner, and to avoid future disputes related to underperformance.

Primary Sources

• NFPA 70, National Electrical Code (NEC), particularly Article 690.

ALT Text Suggestion: An electrician using a Solar Pathfinder tool to conduct a solar shading analysis on a residential rooftop, with the reflective dome showing nearby trees and roof obstructions.